• Home
  • Ezili Dantò
    • Bio of Ezili Danto, 1791
    • About Ezilidanto Spoken Word Dance Theatre
    • Company Profile
  • Performances
    • Touring Season
    • Workshops
    • Press Kit
  • Writings
  • Bio
    • Head Shot
    • Brief Bio
    • Èzili Dantò Merchandise & T-shirts
    • Donate
  • Janjak
  • Blog
  • HLLN/Law
    • News, Essays and Reflections
      • Haiti Perspectives
    • HLLN Public Advocacy Work
    • HLLN Action Alerts
    • FreeHaitiMovement
    • Press Work
  • Contact Us
  • Archives

Port-au-Prince Still Buried Under the Rubble of Competing NGOs

January 8, 2011 Written by Ezili Dantò

Port-au-Prince Still Buried Under the Rubble of Competing NGOs

By Georgianne Nienaber, January 7, 2011, Source: Op Ed News

Both OXFAM and the Disaster Accountability Project released reports this week that enhance already serious criticism of the relationship between the Government of Haiti and NGOs, and the inability of both to offer support to the Haitian people. The reports mark the one-year anniversary of the devastating earthquake that took upwards of 250,000 lives, injured 300,000, and left 1.5 million homeless.

Ask yourselves what’s wrong with these pictures?


Port-au-Prince by Georgianne Nienaber


Port-au-Prince by Georgianne Nienaber



Port-au-Prince by Georgianne Nienaber

Adjacent blocks in downtown Port-au-Prince, late November, 2010 (Copyright G.Nienaber)

Today, the Clinton Bush Haiti Fund announced new grants and investments totaling $3.4 million that promise sustainability and are “aimed at planting the seeds of long-term economic opportunity across Haiti. Note that The Clinton Bush fund is a separate entity from the Haiti Interim Recovery Commission (HIRC), which takes a broadside from OXFAM.

The OXFAM briefing paper reaches deep and does not flinch from indicting the Haiti Interim Recovery Commission, also led by former president Bill Clinton, as it cites a “year of indecision that has left Haiti’s recovery on hold.” There is no coordination between donor agencies as they jostle for control of IDP camps and no effort on the part of the Haitian government to take control of reconstruction, the OXFAM Paper says.

Donors need to stop the “rampant bilateralism — and the often-contradictory policies and priorities that plague the IHRC. They should also co-ordinate much more closely among themselves in order to avoid gaps and duplication in funding. For example, money has been made available for temporary housing, but almost no funds have been allocated for rubble removal.

The caveat to the OXFAM criticism is that OXFAM itself is a powerful NGO that is looking for its own slice of the money pie. If one reads the OXFAM Progress Report (a separate document), you can come away with the notion that OXFAM has singlehandedly kept Haiti alive, and this is certainly not the case. Reader, be aware.

The most troubling aspect of OXFAM’s presentation of the dire situation in Haiti is that OXFAM links its excellent and accurate analysis of the problems in Haiti to its own “progress report.” In fact, if one searched for “OXFAM Haiti Report” on their website you are led directly to their self-aggrandizing “progress report” before you can find their analysis of the reconstruction failures. Of course, the analysis places the blame on other NGOs.

Read the OXFAM documents simultaneously with a critical eye and see what you think.

The Disaster Accountability Project also released their “One Year Report On The Transparency of Relief Organizations Responding to the 2010 Haiti Earthquake.” The report finds near “factual-blackout (s)” in relief and aid organizations’ regular, detailed reporting. Donors are “giving in the dark,” and “appeals to emotion” dominate factual accounting of how and where money is spent, DAP says.

The Disaster Accountability Project (DAP) is a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to improving disaster management systems through policy research and advocacy. DAP was founded in 2007 in reaction to the response to Hurricane Katrina.

Read the full DAP report here.

The report examined 196 organizations that solicited donations for Haiti disaster relief. It determines whether they produced regular, factual reports, the accessibility of the reports, and how the monies raised were spent.

“The fact that nearly half of the donated dollars still sit in the bank accounts of relief and aid groups does not match the urgency of their own fundraising and marketing efforts and donors’ intentions, nor does it covey the urgency of the situation on the ground. This may be a disincentive for future giving by individuals and other governments,” said Ben Smilowitz, DAP’s Executive Director.

Over 1.8 million dollars in interest was reportedly raised by just 5 of the survey respondents. 10 groups reported that they did not know how much interest they have raised and the rest (23 groups) did not respond either way, indicating that this figure is likely higher, the report says.

OXFAM did better than most in response to the questionnaire submitted by DAP. It says that out of $97 million raised for Haiti earthquake relief, $66 million has been disbursed for Haiti relief. 500 staff members are currently working in country. Regarding the interest question, OXFAM says, “current interest rates in secure, short-term investments are at or close to 0%. As a result, no significant income has been generated.”

Zero percent?

Another pressing question, given the cholera epidemic, $66 million from OXFAM, the total humanitarian assistance earmarked for cholera from USAID of $40,802,413, and millions donated to other NGOs is: “Where is the infrastructure for clean water and sanitation?”

Water purification tablets are nothing more than a band-aid.

The answer might lie with the Haitian Grassroots organization, Ayiti Kale Je , which suggests the term NGO is a misnomer, “since many are direct subcontractors of the United States and other governments,” making them Haiti’s largest employer.

This video on the “cash for work” program is very revealing.


The Clinton Bush Haiti Fund promise of $3.4 million in new grants and investments, if the money enhances the Haitian private sector, offers some hope.


Gary Edson, CEO of the Clinton Bush Haiti Fund says “While we as a global community must continue to alleviate the Haitian people’s unacceptable pain, we must also take clear aim at the country’s underlying problems, by offering Haitians the tools and resources they need to build a sustainable economy – one that will help heal their country from within and put Haiti on a path to prosperity.”

To date, the Fund has raised over $52 million, of which more than $20 million has been committed, “the vast majority to projects that further the Fund’s mission of promoting economic growth and empowerment.” A full list of the Fund’s grants and investments can be found here.

Honestly not wanting to be cynical and sincerely wanting these programs to succeed–looking at the organizations that “benefit” from the Clinton Bush Fund–one sees the list of usual suspects of foreign NGOs and religious organizations.

What ever happened to UN Special Envoy Clinton’s promises to the farmers who supply the sugar mill in Darbonne when he visited last June? The mill is still languishing.

Each worker in Haiti cares for an average of 8 people. Since the Darbonne mill has 250 employees and currently works with over 1,000 farmers, the revitalization of the Darbonne Mill translates into the participation of over 30,000 farmers, resulting in a direct positive economic impact on over 240,000 people. If successful, the sugar mill will reduce food imports by 10 percent and reduce South American sugar imports by as much as 40 percent.

Money for this project would demonstrate real progress and would go a long way toward getting the Haitian agricultural economy up and running and removing the obvious stranglehold of foreign interests.

I visited the Darbonne mill in May and can tell you that it rivals any mill currently operating in Louisiana. More than that, the pride of operation speaks volumes about what Haitians can accomplish on their own if only given the opportunity.

Support the Haitian private sector and stop the influence of dueling NGOs, spare us all of the interminable reports, and help move Haiti forward. All that is lacking is real commitment on the part of the international donor community.

NGOs must stop operating as corporations. Only by putting themselves out of business by actually solving problems can they claim success.

****************************************

Recommended HLLN Links
for Jan 8, 2011:

One year after the earthquake, foreign help is actually hurting Haiti

Haiti Earthquake Anniversary: Little Progress, Broken Promises

Haiti reconstruction at ‘standstill,’ says Oxfam report


Haiti suffers after ‘year of indecision’: Oxfam

Haiti Progress Report 2010
An overview of Oxfam’s humanitarian response to the Haitian earthquake

The Betrayal of Haiti

US State Department Briefing on the One Year Anniversary of the Earthquake in Haiti | Jan 7, 2011

Donations to Haiti 1 year after quake

Haiti’s Misery, Our Disgrace

Interviews for Ezili Dantò Witness Project and Free Haiti Movement

The Slavery in Haiti the media won”€™t expose

Expose the lies

Facebook Comments

Add a comment:

comments

Powered by Facebook Comments

News, Essays and Reflections
earthquake, haiti, NGO false benevolence, US false benevolence
Similar posts
  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Co... — The Cost of Liberation: A Conversation with Prof. ...
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block... — Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployme...
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti ... — On November 6, 2023, Èzili Dantò’s Haitian Lawy...
  • UN Will Not Tell You Its Role in the ... — The Haiti Story the Media Won’t Tell You No U...
  • Haiti Weapons Traffickers: CoreGroup&... —  Legal document on 2016 importation of weapons into Hait...
Cuban medics in Haiti put the world to shame
One year after the earthquake, foreign help is actually hurting Haiti

Donate to Ezili’s Haitian Lawyers Leadership Network

zili dlo

Make a donation or monthly subscription

Interview with Marlene Daut on King of Hayti, Henry Christophe
The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason
Haitian leaders write to the African Union
UN Will Not Tell You Its Role in the US-led Corruption, Violence, and Crimes Against Humanity in Haiti
US terrorism in Hayti: Kenya Racial Front and the Sheila McCormick Clueless Konzes
Hayti Revolution For Today’s Revolutionaries
Haiti Weapons Traffickers: CoreGroup’s PHTK Accused but Conveniently Acquitted
PrevNext

Support HLLN: SHOP, SAVE & EARN at Shop.com/cleanwater

Supporters may also make a donation
or monthly subscription

CrossTalk on Haiti: Failed aid

Disaster Capitalism in Haiti, New Orleans, Congo & Pakistan

Follow us

Recent Comments

  • Memories of a Great Guru II – e-Con e-News on Core Group Butchers of Haiti
  • Lala Robinson on Jean Yves Point Du Jour – Yon Gwo Mapou Tonbe, February 3, 2017

Latest Articles

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Clean Water for All

sidebar ad

Vodun Jazzeotry: Ezili Dantò in Red, Black & Moonlight

In the bi-partisan war against Haiti, Obama is General LaPlume the Black general who fought to keep slavery

Multimedia

  • Photogalleries
  • Videos
  • Video Reels
  • Audio

Recent Posts

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Archives

Our bodies are commodities in the commodity culture

RSS RSS Entries

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Zili Dlo: Clean Water and Solar Power For All

Extra_sidebarAdspaceAvailable

Newest Comments

  • Memories of a Great Guru II – e-Con e-News on Core Group Butchers of Haiti
  • Lala Robinson on Jean Yves Point Du Jour – Yon Gwo Mapou Tonbe, February 3, 2017
  • Lala on Celebrating Bwa Kayiman 2017

© copyright 2012-2022 • all rights reserved • ezilidanto.com

7ads6x98y