• Home
  • Ezili Dantò
    • Bio of Ezili Danto, 1791
    • About Ezilidanto Spoken Word Dance Theatre
    • Company Profile
  • Performances
    • Touring Season
    • Workshops
    • Press Kit
  • Writings
  • Bio
    • Head Shot
    • Brief Bio
    • Èzili Dantò Merchandise & T-shirts
    • Donate
  • Janjak
  • Blog
  • HLLN/Law
    • News, Essays and Reflections
      • Haiti Perspectives
    • HLLN Public Advocacy Work
    • HLLN Action Alerts
    • FreeHaitiMovement
    • Press Work
  • Contact Us
  • Archives

CEPR Examines OAS Report on Haiti’s Election, Finds It “Inconclusive, Statistically Flawed, and Indefensible”

January 12, 2011 Written by Ezili Dantò

CEPR Examines OAS Report on Haiti’s Election, Finds It “Inconclusive, Statistically Flawed, and Indefensible”

Jan. 11, 2011, Source: Center for Economic and Policy Research (“CEPR”)

For Immediate Release: January 11, 2011
Contact: Dan Beeton, 202-239-1460

Washington, D.C.– The Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR) has analyzed the Expert Verification Mission’s Final Report from the Organization of American States (OAS) on Haiti’s presidential elections, which has not been released to the public but is now available on the CEPR website here [PDF]. CEPR’s analysis found that the OAS report cannot help determine the outcome of the first round of Haiti’s election.

“This report can”€™t salvage an election that was illegitimate, where nearly three-quarters of the electorate didn”€™t vote, and where the vote count of the minority that did vote was severely compromised,”€ said Mark Weisbrot, CEPR Co-Director and co-author of the report, “Haiti’s Fatally Flawed Election.”€

CEPR has been unable to find a presidential election in the Western Hemisphere, including Haiti, with such a low turnout, going back to 1947. Haiti’s parliamentary election of 2009, in which the country’s most popular political party was also banned, had a turnout of less than 10 percent.

The OAS report does confirm some of the most important conclusions from CEPR’s analysis of the elections, which was published on Sunday. For example, the OAS finds that 12 percent of the tally sheets were either not received by the Provisional Electoral Council or were quarantined – a much larger number of lost votes than the OAS or the Provisional Electoral Council (CEP) had previously publicly acknowledged.

Yet the OAS report concludes that the election should not be re-run, but rather that the results should be changed so that Michel Martelly, rather than the government candidate Jude Celestin, would finish second and therefore proceed to a run-off election.

But it is easy to see that there is no sound basis for such a conclusion. For example, the missing tally sheets came from areas that had a different distribution of votes than the average for the country as a whole – one that favored Celestin. CEPR’s analysis found that if the missing tally sheets had a distribution that was the same as the other tally sheets that were received from the same areas, then Celestin would have finished second, rather than third.

The OAS analysis was also methodologically and statistically flawed in numerous other ways. Unlike the CEPR report, which examined all of the 11,181 tally sheets, and subjected each of the vote totals of the top three candidates to a statistical test to look for irregularities, the OAS team focused on tally sheets that had unusually high voter participation levels. They then subjected this set of tally sheets to the following criteria:

“In accordance with this provision of the law, the Expert Mission set four specific criteria to determine if a PV [tally sheet] should be included: 1) the inclusion or absence of the required signatures of the polling officials on the Procès-Verbal [tally sheet]; 2) the inclusion or absence of the list of registered voters; 3) the presence and accuracy of the CIN [voter national identity] numbers to identify those voters who cast their ballots at that particular polling station; 4) if a Procès-Verbal [tally sheet] had been obviously altered to change the results of the elections, for instance adding a digit to a number to increase a vote total by a hundred or more, that PV [tally sheet] was also excluded.”€

On this basis, the OAS team threw out 234 tally sheets, and with the remaining tally sheets calculated the results.

“This methodology really tells us nothing about who really finished second in the first round of the election, even among the small minority of voters that actually voted and had their votes counted,”€ said Weisbrot.

Weisbrot also noted that the small margin of difference between Martelly and Celestin in the OAS’s recount – 0.3 percent – was too small to statistically distinguish between the two, given the sample size and variance.

“This appears to be a political, and not a professional, decision,”€ Weisbrot added.

###

Facebook Comments

Add a comment:

comments

Powered by Facebook Comments

News, Essays and Reflections
CEPR, elections, haiti, HLLN, Mark Weisbrot, OAS
Similar posts
  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Co... — The Cost of Liberation: A Conversation with Prof. ...
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block... — Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployme...
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti ... — On November 6, 2023, Èzili Dantò’s Haitian Lawy...
  • UN Will Not Tell You Its Role in the ... — The Haiti Story the Media Won’t Tell You No U...
  • Haiti Weapons Traffickers: CoreGroup&... —  Legal document on 2016 importation of weapons into Hait...
One year after the earthquake, foreign help is actually hurting Haiti
HLLN re-members the quake victims with: A bouquet of tears by Michel Sanon

1 Comment

  1. PLou's Gravatar PLou
    January 13, 2011    

    This is one of the very rare good news coming out of Haiti. I am so glad and relieved that the CEPR was not polarized in their decision too because I was literally holding My breath to see what their verdict would be. Alas, our ancestors, the 200,000+ deceased and millions slain, Makandal, our founding Fathers and Mothers, and even Aristide, will be honored by these results. Merci Bon Dieu.
    Just hope better things will follow from this, and Ayisien can continue pushing for change for the MAJORITY population and our country. Bless…

Donate to Ezili’s Haitian Lawyers Leadership Network

zili dlo

Make a donation or monthly subscription

Interview with Marlene Daut on King of Hayti, Henry Christophe
The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason
Haitian leaders write to the African Union
UN Will Not Tell You Its Role in the US-led Corruption, Violence, and Crimes Against Humanity in Haiti
US terrorism in Hayti: Kenya Racial Front and the Sheila McCormick Clueless Konzes
Hayti Revolution For Today’s Revolutionaries
Haiti Weapons Traffickers: CoreGroup’s PHTK Accused but Conveniently Acquitted
PrevNext

Support HLLN: SHOP, SAVE & EARN at Shop.com/cleanwater

Supporters may also make a donation
or monthly subscription

CrossTalk on Haiti: Failed aid

Disaster Capitalism in Haiti, New Orleans, Congo & Pakistan

Follow us

Recent Comments

  • Memories of a Great Guru II – e-Con e-News on Core Group Butchers of Haiti
  • Lala Robinson on Jean Yves Point Du Jour – Yon Gwo Mapou Tonbe, February 3, 2017

Latest Articles

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Clean Water for All

sidebar ad

Vodun Jazzeotry: Ezili Dantò in Red, Black & Moonlight

In the bi-partisan war against Haiti, Obama is General LaPlume the Black general who fought to keep slavery

Multimedia

  • Photogalleries
  • Videos
  • Video Reels
  • Audio

Recent Posts

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Archives

Our bodies are commodities in the commodity culture

RSS RSS Entries

  • The Cost of Liberation: A Powerful Conversation with Prof. Marlene Daut on Henry Christophe, King of Haiti
  • Kenya lawyers file contempt of court against President Ruto and his government for violating court ruling prohibiting deployment to Haiti
  • Haitian American lawyer sues to block US-backed deployment of  Kenyan troops in Haiti
  • VERTIÈRES – Napoleon the Enslaver, Surrenders to Hayti Freedom Fighters
  • Haiti Lawyers Sue the De Facto Haiti Government for Treason

Zili Dlo: Clean Water and Solar Power For All

Extra_sidebarAdspaceAvailable

Newest Comments

  • Memories of a Great Guru II – e-Con e-News on Core Group Butchers of Haiti
  • Lala Robinson on Jean Yves Point Du Jour – Yon Gwo Mapou Tonbe, February 3, 2017
  • Lala on Celebrating Bwa Kayiman 2017

© copyright 2012-2022 • all rights reserved • ezilidanto.com

7ads6x98y